KNOTTINGLEY HOSPITAL SUNDAYS
FROM FAIRS, FESTIVALS, AND FROLICS,
KNOTTINGLEY, circa 1840 – 2003
Volume One (2003)
By Dr TERRY SPENCER B.A (Hons), Ph d
PAGE TWO
In spite of
all incentives and for whatever reason fund-raising at Knottingley
underwent a regressive phase between 1909-1918. The situation was
exacerbated during the Great War which saw the nadir of giving by the
townspeople. In part the decline was caused by even further demands upon
the charitable instinct of the inhabitants as provision of comforts for
local troops was added to the myriad causes already in existence. More
significantly, the enlistment of the young men of the town deprived the
Infirmary Committee of voluntary assistance and income. The adverse effect
may be seen from the public notice concerning the 1916 demonstration with
its plea that "people
are earnestly requested to help to the utmost." (71)
and again the
following year when H.L. Lyon, Chairman of the P.G.I. Management
Committee, stated a need for more workers all year round and appealed from
the public platform for helpers to come forward. (72) Something of the
deprivation in personal terms is seen in a reference by the local M.P. to
the loss of Lt. Arthur Barnell, a keen worker for the cause before the war
and Barnell’s loss typified a general pattern both locally and
nationally. (73) In a financial context loss is seen in the fact that in
1915 only £70 was collected, with less than £4 coming from the licensed
premises which only a few years before had provided at least 50% of all
income. (74)
Knottingley’s
decline is all the more apparent when compared with the effort of
Brotherton. In 1915, Brotherton raised £76, six pounds more than
Knottingley had managed and the following year Brotherton collected £130
compared to Knottingley’s £97. Again, the difference was due to public
house contributions with more than £100 being raised in Brotherton pubs
and only £25 at Knottingley despite the fact that the latter had more
than three times the number of licensed premises. (75)
In an attempt
to redress the balance, Mr. Handel Booth M.P., speaking at the
demonstration held in Charles Elliott’s field at Womersley Road in 1916,
offered 3d. of his own money for every shilling saved by any pub which
raised £20 or more. (76) In addition, Mr. Lyon promised a medal to any
pub which collected in excess of £5 and in 1918, offered a challenge cup
to be presented annually to the public house or club with the highest
amount, the cup to be retained permanently by any house which won it for
three successive years. (77) The purpose of these measures was to
encourage collections on a regular basis, the secret of Brothertons
success. Thus, little Brotherton set the pace for its larger neighbour and
Knottingley responded to the challenge.
In 1918, with
the Mayor of Pontefract, Cr. Oswald Holmes, in attendance at the Banks
Garth cricket field, the people of Knottingley, by the Mayors own
admission, gave him a message to take back to Pontefract. The reason was
"a
record which redounds to the credit of all concerned" in the form
of £281-11-4d., more than £200 in advance of the takings of the previous
year and "a
record for Knottingley or any place in the district."
Apart from
the example and challenge afforded by Brotherton which was duly
acknowledged by the Chairman, Mr. Horace Bentley, the reason for the
remarkable recovery was ascribed as being due to an increased sense of
public awareness and responsibility by the townspeople. (78)
Within the
constraints of the income of the labouring poor there had always been
awareness and responsibility. In the twenty years following the
reconstitution of the local Infirmary Committee in 1897 the sum of
£1,132-18-9d.,a per capita average of £33-13-0 per annum, had been
disbursed to Pontefract Dispensary. Leeds Infirmary had received £133-7-0
or £12-2-5 per person, as an annual average sum and the total per capita
annual average for both institutions was £84-4-0 (79)
Horace
Bentley was undoubtedly right, however, in that the grim unfolding of the
Great War, then entering its final phase, had heightened awareness of the
need to make more effort, from moral conviction as well as practical
necessity. On a psychological level the brutal horror of the war with its
broken minds and bodies, shattered lives and mass slaughter had engendered
a resolve on the part of the survivors to shape a better world. In
addition, the growing sense of relief that the end of the conflict was in
sight doubtless triggered a feeling of joy and thanksgiving which was
manifest in the contributions to the Hospital Fund.
On a more
mundane level, more thorough organisation of public house collections gave
practical benefit to the cause for in 1918 licensed houses, which now
included the Hill Top Workingmens’ Club (which was to be joined shortly
afterwards by those of Foundry Lane, British Legion and National
Association of Discharged Soldiers & Sailors) contributed £144-1-9 or
51% of the record total. (80)
The following
year the record was again broken. A large gathering at Banks Garth was
informed by the Hon’ Secretary of the local Committee, Mr. G. W.
Reynolds, that in 1919 a total of £477-6-5 had been amassed as against
the final tally of £301-14-8 the previous year. Of the new record amount
55% came from public house collections with the Red Lion at Kellington
donating more than £100 and the Wesleyan Brotherhood subscribing
£101-6-0 compared to £38 in 1918. Cr. Reynolds referred to the
unsuccessful attempt by Pontefract to eclipse Knottingley’s effort. The
final sum collected in 1919 was almost £500, a record amount that was
considered to be unbeatable by any other neighbouring township. (81)
The
spectacular financial outcome had been achieved by reorganisation of the
system of collecting in licensed premises and workplaces from late 1917,
the efficiency of which was acknowledged by George Reynolds who as
Secretary had been instrumental in the process of reorganisation. (82)
Amid the
vicissitudes of war more subtle changes affecting the nature of the annual
demonstration had occurred. The presence and participation of the local
clergymen on a regular basis from the turn of the twentieth century
underlined the religious origin of the demonstrations and this link was
further emphasised by the musical content of the annual proceedings,
consisting of selections of sacred music and popular hymns. In deference
to its quasi-religious nature the event customarily began with the singing
of the 23rd Psalm to the tune ‘Old Hundred’.
Similarly,
from the final decade of the nineteenth century the event provided a
platform for the political elements within the local constituency with the
Borough Member and quite regularly his prospective opponent present,
together with local councillors from Knottingley, Pontefract and other
neighbouring townships. While the occasion was not one of overtly
political nature, merely providing a meeting ground for the elected
representatives, their political opponents and the constituents, it is
interesting to note how an increasing emphasis was placed upon the
political aspects of health care from the 1920s.
In a broad
context the trend is discernible from the war years with patriotic fervour
expounded by parliamentary and governmental propagandists. For instance,
the public address of Mr. Handel Booth M.P., were characterised by
strident anti-German oratory and similarly, in 1916, Booth’s sentiments
were echoed by Mr. Philip Doherty, a representative of the Ministry of
Munitions who employed such rhetoric in order to emphasise the need for
increasing war production. Significantly, ‘Old Hundred’ was replaced
by the National Anthem at demonstrations during the war and for some time
thereafter. (83) While such sentiments were publicly acceptable and
understandably so in the context of the period, they were nonetheless a
departure from previous observance and influenced the nature of future
events to a degree.
With the
widespread support of the Labour Party in the 1920s, opinions regarding
state provision of medical services became more polarised with doctrinaire
views based upon party politics increasingly expounded.
Speaking from
the platform in 1920 the Rev. T.A.H. Thomas said that as a result of the
war the public attitude towards hospitals was changing with camps in
favour of voluntary or state aided schemes. Regardless of the pros and
cons of the political theories which informed public attitudes on the
issue, the reverend gentleman drew attention to the financial plight of
nurses who were receiving only £12 a year at that time, less than small
boys were earning in local factories. To underline the disparity it was
stated that out of their meagre income the nurses had to pay for their own
uniforms. (84)
In 1921, Mr.
Tom Smith, the prospective Labour candidate, joined the platform party at
the cricket field and used the opportunity to broach the subject of
hospital waiting lists (plus ca chance…???) which he stated had grown
following the passing of the National Insurance Act and local hospitals
were unable to clear because they were debt ridden. Smith also attacked
bad housing conditions, claiming them a major factor in the spread of
disease. (85)
The following
year George Reynolds, remarking on the adverse effect of the beer tax on
public house collections, expressed regret at the absence of the sitting
M.P., Mr. Walter Forrest, claiming that his presence at the demonstration
might have inclined him to support reduction of the impost. Smith
capitalised on Reynold’s comment, claiming Forrest was "somewhat
afraid of meeting his constituents."
Smith’s
fervour for state funding was however, attacked obliquely by the attendant
Mayor of Pontefract, Cr. Moxon, who alluded to the advocates of such a
system and said it would mean costly, extravagant bureaucracy. The concept
"stank
in their [i.e. opponents’] nostrils. We’ve had enough of it and we don’t
want any more." (86)
Tom Smith was
an M.P. in 1923 when he appeared alongside his political opponent, Major
Braithwaite, D.S.O., M.C., the prospective Unionist candidate. George
Reynolds in stating that Pontefract Dispensary required £3,000 in order
to make it "the
most up to date in the country" again
expressed the hope that the institution would remain a voluntary one
rather than a state aided service. However in admitting that Knottingley
"had
passed through a period of depression as never before"
one senses a
note of reluctant acceptance of the inevitability of state control in the
face of future economic depreciation. Smith, for his part blamed
unemployment for the decrease in contributions that year and said
parliament could have done more by exempting tax from money donated to
hospitals. (87) Thereafter throughout the remainder of his tenure as an
M.P. which (with one hiccup when he was briefly unseated by Brigadier
General C.R. Ingham-Brook, C.M.G., D.S.O.) lasted until 1935, Smith
refrained from making political points. One reason, perhaps was the
reconstitution of the local Infirmary Committee in 1926 but more probably
because the severe economic situation consequent upon the world wide
depression made obvious the impracticality of state funding for a
comprehensive health care system. By the late 1930s however, the cry for a
government sponsored health service had been taken up by hospital
administrators as well as many politicians. At the 1938 demonstration Mr
D.J. Richards, Secretary/Superintendent of the P.G.I., said the government
could do more to help hospitals. Richard’s assertion was well founded.
More than a decade earlier it had been stated that an average
administration cost of £2,000 had risen by 50% by 1924 and that £4,000
per annum would be required in the near future as Pontefract Infirmary
sought to adapt to meet the needs of an ever increasing population. (88)
Faced with an exponential increase in demand it was obvious that voluntary
funding was incapable of meeting future need. Income from voluntary
sources was subject to the vagaries of general economic circumstances and
even in its most prodigious efforts failed to meet the necessary level of
expenditure. A crisis in the financial administration of hospitals and
allied institutions was clearly evident when the outbreak of war in
September 1939 placed the desired remedial action in abeyance for the
duration and a little beyond.
The year 1920
saw a downturn in receipts as the police forbade local public houses to
hold raffles to boost contributions. A glimpse of the effect of the ban is
seen by comparison of some public house contributions in 1919 and 1920,
viz:-
| Name of Pub |
1919 |
1920 |
|
£ |
s |
d |
£ |
s |
d |
| Aire Street Hotel |
21 |
2 |
6 |
1 |
13 |
7 |
| Cherry Tree Inn |
7 |
13 |
3 |
2 |
1 |
3½ |
| L & Y Hotel |
14 |
10 |
11½ |
7 |
4 |
10½ |
The overall
effect was a deficit of about £120 on the amount collected the previous
year which it was claimed would have been exceeded had the pubs had
complete freedom.
Not all
public houses showed a deficit in 1920 however. The Lime Keel Inn, which
was described as a ‘pioneer’ in collecting for the P.G.I. and had
received more medals than any other local pub, raised £24 compared to
£17-5-10 in 1919. Similarly, the Sailors Home, which had donated £5-6-9
in 1919, raised its contributions to £18-11-71/2. Increases such as the
above reflected the fervour of the individual licensees, a fact
acknowledged in the award of medals to Mrs Downing of the Lime Keel and
Mrs Lavin of the Sailors Home. The starkest reduction in contributions was
seen in the case of the Red Lion, Kellington, which fell from more than
£100 in 1919 to a mere £2-1-0 in the succeeding year. Perhaps the reason
for the decline is to be found in a change of tenancy with a less
enthusiastic tenant taking over the Inn?
Despite a
decline in the overall sum collected, 1920 was nevertheless a successful
year, one which Secretary George Reynolds "doubted
if any other township would beat."
The street
collections along the processional route set a record of £9-0-5 and the
year was also the first of a series of successive years marked by the
individual effort of schoolgirl, Kathleen Mary Roberts, who collected the
sum of 10 guineas and received a brooch from Mr Horace Bentley, Chairman
of Knottingley’s Infirmary Committee in recognition of here effort. (89)
Adults
involved in the administration of the local fund raising effort were
rightly mindful of the need to encourage the participation of the younger
generation. When, in 1919, Boy Scout, George Ella, took part in the
en-route collection, his effort was recognised by one of the regular
collectors, Mr J. Chapman, who generously declined to accept the medal
awarded for the highest sum collected in the parade in order that the
prize could be bestowed upon the youngster. (90) The award was therefore
the precursor to the prize received by Miss Roberts who in 1923 received a
wristlet watch for collecting £8-17-11 while the runner-up, Master George
Hall, who collected £7-18-0., received a silver pen knife. (91)
In recording
the achievements of those mentioned above it is appropriate to digress in
order to note the developmental pattern and contribution made to the cause
by young people in later years. Pride of place in 1924 went to Miss Elsie
Broughton who received a box of hankies while Kathleen Roberts and George
Hall received scent and a watch respectively. (92) Miss Broughton
continued to dominate individual collections in the years immediately
following and by 1928 had amassed a combined total of £60. Retiring that
year, Miss Broughton waived her right to a medal in favour of newcomer
Master Thomas Miller. (93) For three successive years thereafter, Thomas
Miller won the medal, together with a wrist watch in 1929. (94) In 1933
Miss Dorothy Asquith won the medal and a watch and received the medal
again the following year. (95) In 1935 the recipient of the medal and
watch was Miss Muriel Brooks, who, in 1936 was one of four schoolgirl
collectors who collectively raised £26-8-0 of which Miss Brooks attained
the highest amount with £17. (96) Achieving the hat-trick in 1937, Muriel
then yielded the prize to Miss Irene Cawthorne in 1938. (97)
Proving the
benefit of early recruitment was John Firth who at the age of four won the
prize for the highest sum collected by a child in 1940 and again the
following year when he was presented with a model railway engine, an
appropriate prize for John lived in the gatehouse at the Womersley Road
railway crossing. (98) A fellow recipient of the prize in 1941 was Master
W. Bagley. From 1942-1944 George Tennant won the first prize and John
Firth was the runner-up. (99) In Victory Year, 1945, Roly Tennant, brother
of George, was first with John Firth again a prize winner. (100) The two
final years of Infirmary Sunday fund raising were the preserve of Miss
Pamela Kellett. In 1944 Pam won the award for the best street collection
and repeated her success in 1945 before taking the prize for the best
individual collection in 1946 and 1947 with a young Eric Horton a fellow
recipient in the former year. (101)
The valuable
contribution of Pam Kellett and her sister Marjorie in collecting money
for local charities cannot be overstated. For more than a decade during
the war and in the immediate post war period, the talented ‘K’ Sisters
were the predominant fund raisers in the area, specialising in raising
money for Pontefract General Infirmary. The girls are warmly remembered by
many of the older inhabitants of Knottingley more than half a century
later. (102)
Nor in paying
tribute to the dedication of those casually associated with Hospital
Sunday should one ignore a Mr Selway. A regular hand with a collecting tin
along the processional route in the years immediately preceding the Second
World War, Mr Selway, on leave from the R.A.F. in 1941, joined the parade
with his collection tin and with the sum of £1-8-0, won the prize for the
highest sum collected for the second time in his years of association with
the cause. (103)
A notable
team effort in 1920 was the effort of the Wesleyan Brotherhood which
raised in excess of £100 for the second successive year and was to go on
to complete a hat-trick of centuries the following year.
A prominent
figure on the platform at that time was Alderman T.J. Sides, Mayor of
Pontefract and Managing Director of Carter’s Knottingley Brewery Co.
Ltd., who offered a silver cup, valued at 10 guineas, to be competed for
by the Company’s houses (which constituted the majority of the public
houses in Knottingley) and retained by any house winning it for three
successive years. Addressing the public in 1920, Sides, mindful of the
slight decline in the sum contributed, stated that as wages in the
locality had increased, he had hoped to see a corresponding increase in
workers donations. In order to ensure a future increase, Sides suggested
that Sunday School teachers initiate a system of collection amongst their
scholars. Receiving the silver Lyon Cup in his capacity as Secretary of
the Hill Top Workingmens’ Club, G.W. Reynolds responded to Sides
remarks, stating that the workingmen did well "and
that they [the committee] ought to have more from the other side [the
employers]." (104)
Sides
disparagement of the workers efforts was put into perspective in 1922
when, again in the presence of Sides, Reynolds while describing the
Knottingley people as "second to none", reported that
workpeoples’ donations were down a s a result of wage reductions for
which there had been no corresponding reduction in the cost of living,
leaving him to wonder "how
working people had managed to subscribe so well to obtain within £14 of
the previous year."
The ‘knock-on’
effect of the deteriorating economic situation was also seen in reduced
public house contributions, although the high rate of tax on beer was a
contributory factor. Also, the Wesleyan Brotherhood with a contribution of
£79 fell short of £100 for the first time in recent years. Even so, the
Hon Treasurer of the Knottingley Infirmary Committee, Cr. Jackson Morris,
comparing the effort of fund raising as a ‘Christ like’ activity, was
able to announce that for the third successive year the overall total
would exceed £400. Two elements in this success were the increased
emphasis given to collecting in the surrounding rural areas, particularly
the villages of Beal and Kellington which resulted in a fivefold increase
in rural contributions, and an anonymous cheque for £30 sent "in
order to augment the splendid total which Knottingley raises for the
hospitals year by year." (105)
In 1924 Hill
Top Workingmens’ Club won the Sides Cup outright, being the highest
contributors among the licensed premises for the third year with
successive totals of £4-4-2, £38-18-4 and £62-9-2.
The Chairman
remarked that the people of Knottingley " taught
Pontefract every year what could be done by organisation and set a fine
example for Brotherton and Ferrybridge despite bad trade."
Nevertheless,
one statistic quoted reveals the deficiencies arising from the dependence
upon voluntary funding. Leeds Infirmary had received 242 patients from
Knottingley at a total cost of £600 and had received a mere £146 from
the town of which sum £125 was donated by the local committee. Even to
reach the goal of £500 would not be a cost effective exercise. In
reviewing this obvious and long standing deficiency Mr H.L. Lyon,
presiding, revealed the fact that "In the
old days a feeling existed that Pontefract got all it wanted and therefore
all the money should go to Leeds."
While the
statement bespeaks the community’s awareness of the debt owed to Leeds
Infirmary and a desire to do all possible to minimise it, it seems
somewhat surprising that maximisation of the effort should be advocated at
the expense of the local Dispensary for not only was there an equal
awareness of debt owed to that institution but, arising from statistics
quoted at the annual demonstration, knowledge that the Dispensary
undertook treatment at a financial loss. Acknowledging that both
institutions were hard up Lyon suggested that 75% of contributions be sent
to Pontefract to help fund the recent extension. Lyon also expressed
regret that the name of the Dispensary had been changed and gave his
opinion that in this respect the Infirmary authorities had made a mistake.
(106)
Like all
outdoor events Infirmary Sunday was a hostage to the weather yet the
August date usually endured favourable conditions over the years. An
exception occurred in 1925, however, when much needed rain following a
period of prolonged drought fell inopportunely, drenching Knottingley
Silver Prize Band and accompanying persons in their march round the town
prior to the demonstration. The event was therefore held in the Town Hall
where soaked but undeterred the bandsmen played a musical selection at the
start of the proceedings instead of during the event and then departed for
their respective homes and a change of clothes. One positive outcome of
the Band’s determination to complete the processional route was that
people showed their appreciation of the marchers by producing a record sum
for the on route collection with Mr. A. Westerman collecting the sum of
£6-4-71/2. In thanking the band for its loyalty to the cause the
Secretary of the local Infirmary Committee recalled similar weather two
years earlier when William Bagley (since deceased), had made up a
shortfall of £9-10-0 in the gate receipts
Appreciation
for the band "who
were always ready to assist" had been
expressed on that occasion and deservedly so for the cause (and indeed,
the town) had no more dedicated body of men. For more than half a century,
led principally by the diminutive but stout-hearted bandmaster, Samuel
Marshall, the band gave its services free of charge making its fiftieth
appearance at the 1946 demonstration on which occasion the Pontefract
General Infirmary Committee presented two briar pipes to Marshall as a
token of appreciation for unparalleled service. (107) Heavy rain also
marred the demonstration in 1932 when the event was transferred to the
Town Hall. Fortunately on this occasion the rain commenced in time for the
parade to be cancelled and thereby prevented the bandsmen from a further
soaking. In referring to the role of the Band in passing it is worth
recalling the somewhat singular circumstances of 1917 when for some
inexplicable reason instead of leading the parade the Prize Band brought
up the rear of the procession. (108)
It is
somewhat ironic that diminished receipts due to the heavy rain in 1925
occurred in the year which witnessed the opening of a new in-patient wing
at the P.G.I. The new wards were named after Mary, the Princess Royal, and
Mr. Marshall, a local confectionery manufacturer, who was the current
chairman of the P.G.I. Management Committee. There was local
disappointment that no recognition had been given to the town of
Knottingley which during the six most recent years had donated £2,000.
(109)
Crisis
occurred in 1926 following the resignation of Secretary, George Reynolds,
for personal reasons. The local Committee looked leaderless and doomed. As
in 1890 a town meeting was called in the hope of appointing a new
committee. The meeting was chaired by Mr. Horace Bentley on the evening of
Thursday, 13th May, 1926, and attended by about 60 persons. Mr.
A. Berry, K.U.D.C. Accountant and shortly afterwards Clerk to the Council,
was appointed Secretary, pro tem, and it was decided to circularise all
clubs, workplaces, schools, and social organisations and request
representatives to serve on a newly formed Infirmary Committee. (110) As a
result a new Committee was subsequently formed with only ten weeks in
which to prepare for the annual demonstration.
The new
Infirmary Committee consisted of Cr. J. Jackson J.P., President, Cr
Jackson Morris, Treasurer, Cr E. Jackson, Chairman and Mr A Pickard,
Secretary. Other prominent members and supporters were Mr S.B.Bagey,
Mr.H.Bentley, Cr A Macdonald and Rev. J.Bennetts, the Wesleyan Minister.
(111)
Contrary to
expectation the change in the management gave a spur to events at
Knottingley and the event was crowned with success. A large gathering in
the Cricket Field was informed that £383-6-4 had been raised compared
with £419-19-81/2 the previous year and was a creditable reflection on
the new Committee and workers. Overall, a record £760 was collected in
1926 beating the previous highest amount of £485 (112) The sum raised was
all the more creditable for being obtained at a time when the effects of
the General Strike had caused widespread distress within the local
community with soup kitchens being set up to feed the children of many
impoverished working class families. The revival was marked by a 150%
increase in workplace subscriptions and a rise of 50% in private donations
while an appreciable increase in public house and club donations was also
discernible. On an individual level the year was notable for the
presentation of a silver cup to Miss Broughton who had collected £11 and
a significant effort by Mr J.G. Westerman who collected £37-7-0 in a
single day’s activity. A novel feature was an award to ‘Rover’, a
retriever dog belonging to Mr A. Rush who had assisted his owner in the
collection of money for the Infirmary. (113)
An
interesting aspect of the addresses delivered from the platform was the
growing demand made on hospital services due to the rise in accidents
arising from the increased volume of road transport.
In presenting
the annual report of the P.G.I. Management Committee in 1927 the Hospital
Chairman revealed that the institute had a deficit of £900 over the
previous year. It is also significant that the effort of the members of
the Knottingley Infirmary Committee and the townspeople who supported them
were singled out for congratulation. (114)
Phoenix like
the reborn administration flourished. In 1928 £950 was collected,
breaking all previous records. Mr W.H. Marshall on behalf of the P.G.I.
stated that for its size Knottingley was better organised than anywhere
else in the country. In a year of all round improvement special thanks
were accorded to both Bandmaster Marshall and the Silver Prize Band and
also to the fairground showpeople for their continuous support since 1896.
The effect of
the opening of the new 15 bed wing at the P.G.I. in 1925, making a 40 bed
capacity, was seen in statistics quoted at the 1928 demonstration. Viz:-
| Date |
Pontefract Patients |
Leeds Patients |
|
IN |
OUT |
IN |
OUT |
| 1925 |
25 |
--- |
69 |
143 |
| 1927 |
61 |
291 |
26 |
85 |
and the swing
from Leeds Infirmary to Pontefract Infirmary continued during the
following decade so that by 1936 Pontefract Infirmary had 144 in-patients
and 350 out-patients referred from the neighbourhood of Knottingley
compared to 25 and 86 respectively, who received treatment at Leeds. (115)
Noting the
increasing recourse to the local hospital the former Chairman of the P.G.I.
Management Committee, Mr H.L. Lyon, mentioned en passant, that when he had
retired from the Chairmanship in 1925, £500 had been raised, a record sum
which was thought to be unique and would not be matched again. Of the
current sum of £950 he hoped 80% would be allocated to Pontefract,
particularly as there was more scope for fund-raising at Leeds with its
dense population and catchment area. In the event it was decided to split
£750 between the two institutions and use the balance to engage a
district nurse to attend cases at Knottingley not referred to the P.G.I.
(116) The return of the district nurse to the town restored a necessary
service lost due to lack of financial provision almost a quarter of a
century earlier. (117)
The year 1928
was also significant in that for the first time in many years two bands
participated in the demonstration. The Salvation Army Band which had made
a solitary appearance 39 years before now returned and the following year
the pre demonstration parade was split into two processions commencing as
separate entities at either end of the town before joining together as
they approached Banks Garth for the demonstration. Thus a new feature was
launched which with only slight modification of one of the routes, was to
provide the pattern for two decades, ending only with the obsolescence of
Infirmary Sunday in 1948.
In 1928
Knottingley Silver Prize Band accompanied by contingents of the local St
Johns Ambulance Brigade, the Church Lads Brigade and Girl Guides, marched
from the Railway Hotel through Hill Top and along Weeland Road while the
Salvation Army Band together with the Boy Scouts and the Girls Life
Brigade travelled from the Low End of the town via Aire Street and Cow
Lane, both meeting at Banks Garth.
At the venue
the Secretary of the local Committee, Mr A. Pickard, was able to announce
that at a time when unemployment had reached a level hitherto unknown, the
town had achieved a long desired ambition by raising over £1,000 in the
past year, thereby breaking all records. The total represented a
percentage increase of 350 over the sum raised the first year following
the reorganisation of the Committee. Apart from the labours of the
Committee, the success owed much to the dedication of local individuals
such as Mr J. Hanson who had served as a gate steward since 1890 and whose
contribution was honoured that year and who was still recorded as
providing stalwart service in 1932. (118)
A further
change announced the following year was the award of the Sides Cup and two
medals for the two largest club boxes with effect from 1930 as it was
considered that public houses could not be expected to compete with local
clubs whose large regularised memberships provided more opportunity for
fund raising than was afforded by the more casual clientele of the pubs.
The situation was clearly evident in 1929 when three of the top four
places were occupied by workingmens’ clubs. The N.A.D.S. & S Club
was awarded the Lyon Cup and winners medal for £29-4-3. By comparison the
Rd Lion, Kellington, occupied third place with £8-10-5 and Foundry Lane
Club ironically, a former public house – the Jolly Sailor – was fourth
with £8-9-91/2. (119)
Attainment of
£1,000 set the trend for future years. In 1931 a further record was set
amidst severe trade depression and mass unemployment with £1,133 being
collected. Despite unparalleled economic adversity the townspeople made a
superhuman effort, falling slightly short of the target sum. However, the
Chairman, Mr A. McDonald made up the deficit to ensure attainment of the
desired goal. Again, in 1932, when £989-9-8 was reached the amount was
rounded off by Mr S.B. Bagley. (120)
With only one
exception the years 1930-1943 saw sums raised in excess of £1,000, viz:-
| YEAR |
TOTAL |
YEAR |
TOTAL |
|
£ |
|
£ |
| 1928 |
760 |
1936 |
1,100 |
| 1929 |
965 |
1937 |
1,130 |
| 1930 |
1,133 |
1938 |
1,070 |
| 1931 |
1,108 |
1939 |
1,066 |
| 1932 |
1,000 |
1940 |
1,220 |
| 1933 |
988 |
1941 |
1,350 |
| 1934 |
1,010 |
1942 |
1,800 |
| 1935 |
1,008 |
1943 |
2,250 |
For a
community of about 7,000 people the figures above are quite remarkable,
particularly in an era of unprecedented socio-economic adversity. While
it is true that from 1927 an annual carnival and sports supplemented
annual takings by the Infirmary Committee the additional sums came from
the restricted incomes of the local inhabitants. Just how hard the
potential income of the Infirmary was hit by high level unemployment is
shown by reference to various sources of donation during the years of
depression. Less people in work meant a smaller workforce to subscribe to
the cause either generally or more particularly via workplace donations.
Likewise, less money to spend resulted in a decline in public house and
club takings while local firms, feeling the adversity of trade depression,
contributed less to the funds raised.
In 1934, Mr
W. Dickinson took over from Mr A. Pickard as Secretary of the local
Infirmary Committee. the change appears to have been a temporary measure
for the following year the post was filled by Mr J.W. Underwood who
retained the office and filled the demanding duties of Secretary until the
disbandment of the Committee in 1948.
An innovative
feature introduced in 1927 was the placement of a giant barometer on the
front of the Town Hall in order to inform the passing public of the rate
of increase in hospital subscriptions. So successful was the measure that
it was revived during the Second World War as a means of indicating funds
subscribed in the annual War Savings Weeks. The ‘barometer’ was
erected by permission of the Council and the formal ceremony marking its
use was presided over by the K.U.D.C. Chairman, Cr. John Jackson, J.P.,
accompanied by Mr M. Lyon, the P.G.I. representative who set the
indicator. The ceremony was distinguished by the presence of the ever
reliable Silver Prize Band who entertained the assembled public with
musical selections. (122) A ‘reverse borrowing’ took place in 1936
when the Infirmary Committee adopted an idea first used in 1929 to raise
funds for the provision of playing fields within the town. At that time
the compilation of a ‘mile of pennies’ had been a novel feature. Seven
years on the Infirmary Committee reintroduced the concept as a ‘mile of
sixpences’ in order to assist the financing of the P.G.I. extension.
(123)
A widening of
disbursements was a notable feature of 1936 for apart from £502 and £200
donated to Pontefract and Leeds hospitals, £150 was given to the
Knottingley Nursing Association and incidental payments of £4-19-0 to the
Royal Bath Hospital, Harrogate, and £21-15-10 to the P.G.I. to provide
new tables for the board room, were also made. (124)
The
collection of £1,000 plus in 1940 was all the more remarkable because of
government restrictions on fundraising activities such as the Carnival and
Sports and special events such as dances, concerts and whist drives
arising from the exigencies of war. Even when in subsequent years a degree
of adaptation to war time conditions permitted a more relaxed and settled
existence the demands of the war effort with its emphasis on National
Savings provided competition for charitable causes by vying for peoples’
money.
The inter war
years had witnessed the development of Council housing along Womersley
Road and the beginnings of the Broomhill estate close by. In order to
capitalise in these centres of population it was decided that the 1940
parade route be altered with the Salvation Army Band and its accompanying
contingent commencing the march from the top of Womersley Road instead of
from Low Green. (125) The following year the Silver Prize Band took the
new route while the Salvation Army Band marched along the route from the
Railway Hotel, Hill Top. For reasons unknown, in 1943 the Salvation Army
Band covered the Womersley Road march and retained this route ever after.
The
demonstration of 1943 proved to be the apogee of the Infirmary Sunday
movement at Knottingley for that year the record sum of £2,250 was
obtained. In a large measure the attainment of that sum was produced by a
myriad activities launched under the joint aegis of the Council, local
Services Welfare Association and the Infirmary Committee. The fact that
full employment ensured full pockets while wartime austerity imposed
constraints upon consumer so ending proved a boon to local charities. (126)
The
penultimate year of the war saw a total of £2,150 raised. A joyful
feature of that years event was the introduction of the Carnival Queen,
Miss Peggy Lowther, and her attendants to the gathering, a sure sign of
public belief in a brighter future, the Carnival having been in abeyance
since 1940. (127)
Victory year,
1945, marked a near challenge to the record of 1943. By the time of the
demonstration a sum approximately equal to the 1943 total had been secured
and outstanding pledges suggested the attainment of a new record. Alas, it
was not to be, the final total of £2,236 falling £14 short of the
record. (128) It has always seemed a source of wonder to the writer that
one of the wealthy local dignitaries did not emulate the action of William
and Stanley Bagley or A McDonald in earlier years and donate a sum
sufficient to crown Victory Year in a fitting way.
The years
1946 and 1947 saw a decline in contributions. The landslide election of a
Labour government in 1945 with its manifesto pledge implement the
recommendations of the Beveridge Report and establish a National Health
Service engendered a degree of anticipation characterised by a relaxation
in public donations. Thus in 1946 the sum raised was £1,091, followed by
£1,218 in 1947, neither sum to be despised as a effort by a community
suffering from fatigue induced by sacrificial demands created by six years
of grim and brutal warfare. (129)
Although the
event of 1947 had a retrospective air in anticipation of the imminent
National Health Service it was by no means certain at that date that the
demonstration would be the last in a link of such events commencing in
1884. Thus, having outlined the provisions of the National Health Service
Act to the large crowd in attendance, Professor R.E. Tunbridge O.B.E., of
Leeds, appealed for continued support in order to hand over the existing
system to the new administrators as ‘a going concern.’ (130)
As events
transpired the 1947 Infirmary Sunday was the last ever. In retrospect one
can see that (largely because of the uncertainty at the time) the final
demonstration was an anti climax to the whole cycle. It must be noted,
however, that such feeling was not apparent in the attitude and conduct of
those present upon that occasion, the present writer being an eye witness
to the event.
For over 60
years Knottingley’s Hospital Sunday was a supreme manifestation of
individual endeavour encapsulated in community action. Today, whatever the
perceived deficiencies of the National Health Service, society has the
assurance of health care to which generations before the mid-twentieth
century could only aspire. Yet in obtaining such a degree of security,
society has lost the spirit of mutual assistance and community pride which
gave Knottingley of yore its unique vibrancy and character and today’s
inhabitants are the poorer for that loss.
In
conclusion, it must be noted that for each person mentioned in this study
there are hundreds of others whose efforts, either by a self denying
desire for anonymity or the caprice of time, are unrecorded in the annals
of the town. The contribution of the nameless ones if of no less value for
being neglected nor is the debt of gratitude owed to them by succeeding
generations.
Memento et
valete ac plaudite.
"Gaiety
was undimmed even by the burden of trade depression. Almost every house
and cottage was decorated from end to end of the straggling town. The
Flatts, as usual, were garlanded….The procession would have done credit
to a much larger town."
Pontefract
& Castleford Express 15th July, 1938
"Can you
think back to the Carnivals
and garland
threaded streets?
Jimmy
Hollingworth was the leading man
Behind these
decorative feats."
"Carnival
Day’s approaching,
Let’s shout
‘hip, Hip, Hooray’,
With comic
bands and stalls and stands
We’ll have
a lovely day…
….The
streets are trimmed from end to end
The curtains
all washed clean
The big day
is upon us
A local
beauty Queen
Howards Field
is the rendezvous
Where
everyone will meet
When the
Queen and her procession
Have passed
the bottom of your street."
Frank
Chambers
‘Memories
of Old Knottingley’ & ‘A journey Around Old Knottingley’
Carey J
Chambers (ed)
Dr. Terry Spencer
Reproduced with the kind permission of Dr. Terry Spencer
Knottingley's Hospital Sundays is copyright ©Terry Spencer 2003
<PAGE ONE
|