UBIQUITOUS AMBASSADORS
KNOTTINGLEY SILVER BAND
by TERRY SPENCER B.A. (Hons), Ph D.
CHAPTER FOUR - PAGE THREE
THE POST WAR PERIOD 1945 - 1960
CONTENTS |
PAGE ONE |
PAGE TWO |
PAGE THREE |
The fees tendered by the Band for engagements during the 1950s were
somewhat random, depending on the nature of the event concerned and the
distance of the venues involved. By 1956 for example, a series of Sunday
concerts commanded the following fees:
Pontefract & Castleford: £30
Wakefield: £35
Leeds: £40
and these charges remained unchanged to the end of the decade. (94)
Similarly, Loscoe Carnival, 1952 and 1953, and Methley Carnival in 1953
and 1954 were charged at £20 respectively although the fee for the
latter event in 1951 was £17-10-0. (95) Other engagements during the
decade were likewise charged in accordance with the time spent
fulfilling the required duties and the expense involved in travelling to
the event. An outdoor Labour day celebration at Goole in 1951 brought a
fee of £15 while a church fete at Ferrybridge was undertaken for £8-10-0
and an indoor concert at Westgate Common Club, Wakefield, as late as
1959 was undertaken for only £7. (96) Such engagements were punctuated
with concerts at local hospitals and social institutions for which, in
the best traditions of service to the community, no fee was sought. (97)
To place the purchasing power of fees in a comparative context it should
be noted that in 1953 a pound sterling would have bought 16 pints of
beer compared to half a pint in 2003, or 15 portions of fish and chips
and 39 large loaves of bread compared to half a portion and two loaves
half a century later. (98)
Throughout the early years of the 1950s the Ladies Committee was
involved quite frequently in organising dances to secure funds for the
Band. Knottingley Town Hall was the regular venue with two such events
during 1951. (99) Again, in 1955 some 20 posters were commissioned to
advertise the event, the price of admission being 2s 6d and the success
of the vent resulted in its replication the following year. (100) It is
interesting to note that the music for dancing was provided by the
locally based Dominoes Dance Band, a far cry from the less sophisticated
pre war era when the ‘Orchestral’ component of the Prize Band provided
the dance music. (101)
By the mid 1950s the effect of television programmes which had gained a
wider audience with the introduction of the commercial channels in 1955,
had fostered the desire for home entertainment which was complemented by
the introduction by Davenports of the ‘beer at home’ delivery service.
In addition, an increasing element of the public became vehicle owners
at this period and were able to travel far afield in search of new, more
novel forms of entertainment and pleasure. By the end of the decade
traditional forms of entertainment such as sport, cinema, public houses,
concerts and dances had lost much of their earlier appeal. The tow
latter forms of entertainment were consequently rendered less useful as
a source of funding for the Band and although a dance was held in the
Town Hall under the auspices of the Band as late as February 1958,
thereafter such occasions were merely a memory. (102)
It is sad to note a degree of indiscipline was prevalent within the
ranks of the Band during the immediate post war period. A reaction to
the constraints of wartime and the psychological effect of regime change
combined with a change in the attitude of the public in general towards
deference to authority based upon wealth and its concomitant social
status, may lie at the root of the situation. In an effort to remedy the
malaise the Committee decreed in 1949 that the Bandmaster should address
the members and stress the need for more satisfactory rehearsals, a sine
qua non for successful contests to which the Band aspired. (103) The
unauthorised swapping of instruments was a further aspect of
indiscipline requiring prohibition if consistency of performance was to
be achieved (104) but much more serious was the evident disrespect of
some members resulting in a proposal by the Vice Chairman
“That anyone insulting or guilty of
insubordination toward the Bandmaster
be dealt with by the Committee.” (105)
At a Committee meeting held in October 1949 a decision was taken to
call a general meeting as soon as possible on “business of vital
importance.” The subject of the meeting is unspecified and no minutes
appear to have been taken but it is not improbable that the meeting was
related to rank and file attitude and conduct. Indeed, despite attempts
at corrective action, problems with two members in particular persisted
for the best part of a decade. (106) Undependability allied to a refusal
to observe rules led to threats of disciplinary action culminating in
expulsion (107) followed by reinstatement only for the offending parties
to err again before the “spasmodic availability” and “past
somewhat troublesome record” resulted in a ‘round robin’ being
signed by the entire membership, dispensing with the services of one of
the recalcitrant only for one dismissed party to be admitted at a later
date. (108)
It is clear that the tolerance shown to such members was not due to
moral weakness on the part of the Committee but from reliance upon their
musical ability at a time when rebuilding was taking place but was far
from complete. For this reason disciplinary action was frequently
postponed until after a particular event. (109)
A degree of indiscipline as shown it turning up late for rehearsals has
been a perpetual problem within the Band but during the 1950s
non-attendance for protracted periods was a problem to the extent that
the Secretary was occasionally called upon to ascertain whether absentee
bandsmen had any future intention of attending at all. As late as 1959
the concern of the Committee resulted in the decision to keep a register
and deal with anyone who missed 25% of rehearsals in any six month
period. (110)
Indications of the long term effect of wartime disruption is clearly
evident in the degree of improvisation during the decade from 1945 with
‘blooding’ of inexperienced players, recruitment of new members and
negotiations for the appearance of guest players as an interim measure.
Thus it is recorded that:
“A.W. to play the drum at Cliffe and receive a full share” [of the
fee], and “P.M. to be given one month’s trial and then be a full member
if successful”, and that “E.E. be asked to join the Band as a
‘pumper-up.”
Meanwhile, the Secretary was to “interview C.B. with a view to him
playing B-B flat at the Leicester concert”, and with regard to a
forthcoming event, negotiate for “a trombone player to be engaged on
terms to be arranged.” (111)
As late as 1951 it was necessary for the Band to seek assistance in
order to fulfil engagements, particularly in the case of the Festival of
Britain gala event and in one case the Secretary wrote to the commanding
officer of the bandsman who was undergoing National Service to seek
leave for the player to appear with the Band at a forthcoming contest.
(112)
A ‘Youth Policy’ was seen as a necessity for long-term growth and
stability, the more so as several long serving members were
contemplating retirement from the Band on grounds of age. Frank Spencer,
Tom Tingle, Billy Rowbottom and C. Jackson all resigned during the
‘Fifties and early ‘Sixties. (113) Fortunately, admittances kept pace
with departures and by the mid 1960s when Tom Pollard and Roland Hey
retired the Band had a complement of 24 members, the youngest of whom
was only ten years of age. (114)
One area of recruitment of young people was through an approach to the
headmaster of the local secondary school, Mr. S. Roebuck, to see his
assistance regarding the provision of potential learners. The Committee
also decided to establish a beginner’s class and in anticipation of this
measure agreed to purchase six B-flat cornets suitable for use by junior
bandsmen. (115) the scale of the project was obviously far too demanding
to be left solely in the hands of the bandmaster, no matter how
efficient or willing to bear the burden. competent members were
therefore enlisted from within the ranks of the Band to assist in
teaching learners and featuring instruments other than the cornet and
Terry Clayton and E Ashley volunteered to teach and played a significant
part in the promotion of ‘young blood’ within the Band. (116)
A further aspect of functional reform commencing in the post war period
was the attempt to rebuild the Band music library. Owing to the lack of
adequate supervision members had adopted a very casual attitude to items
belonging to the Band library and in June 1949 it was decreed by the
Committee that, “all music taken from the Bandroom [is] to be signed
for.”
A donation by Joe and Brian Pollard enabled the purchase of several new
scores at that time (117) but the need to appoint a librarian with
personal responsibility for cataloguing and maintaining and ordering new
scores does not appear to have been considered, perhaps because of the
reluctance of anyone to volunteer for the duty. It was therefore not
until 1965 that Raymond Hodgson, son of the then Secretary, and one of
the younger bandsmen, became the librarian. It was resolved that, “all
members [are] to seek out and return all Band music so that an
assessment of the library can be made.” (118)
The desire for a comprehensive ‘tidying-up’ is manifest from the early
1950s and applied to the public appearance of the Band as well as to the
internal aspects of discipline as shown by a resolution concerning the
image of the Band when on parade, with the injunction that the; “Bandmaster
[is] to pay special attention to the step adopted when the Band sets off
on the march, to ensure the proper formation is maintained.” (119)
The problems and privations experienced by the Band in the aftermath of
the war did not prevent it contesting. On the 18th May 1946 the band was
awarded 3rd prize in the Open Championships at Bell Vue, Manchester, in
which 28 bands representing the northern counties took part. Despite
being depleted by war service the test piece ‘Hereward’ was rendered by
an ensemble in which all but two members had been taught by Sammy
Marshall. Owing to an administrative error a rival band was named in 3rd
place and Knottingley Band was left on tenterhooks until an official
correction was made. (120)
The Band was less successful in the North Eastern Championships held in
the Belgrave Hall, Leeds, on Saturday 6th May 1950. Competing in the
Fourth Section the Band drew the 25th playing order out of 21 contesting
bands which meant a six hour wait before being called upon to play. The
Band, with 170 marks out of 200 was well down the list, the winner being
the City of York Band with 190 marks. In an echo of former days, Mr.
A.H. Whitehead of Sturton, Leeds, had been engaged as guest conductor
for the occasion. (121)
In the contest held at the same venue the following year the band was
again unplaced, gaining 173 points out of 200, but the contest proved
valuable experience for several young players for whom the occasion
provided and initiation in competitive playing. (122)
For the Daily Herald sponsored contests in 1952 the Band was reinforced
by the appearance of at least one guest player. In addition, Band
practice was extended to cover two evenings per week. (123) The Band
took part in several contests each year, at Osset, at Halifax and at
Huddersfield on the 14th March 1953, conducted on each occasion by Mr.
Whitehead. (124) Several of the above events were under the aegis of the
West Riding Brass Band Society of which Knottingley Band was a long
established member. Others were organised by the Halifax Brass Band
Society. (125) The events were very much a learning experience for the
members of the Silver Prize Band as shown by the post contest evaluation
following the Osset contest in October 1953 which was described as being
“enjoyable and successful.” (126)
The Daily Herald contest at Huddersfield on the 13th March 1954 also
appears to have been successful and in its wake A.H. Whitehead was
presented with an inscribed watch-metronome. (127) That year the Band
again entered the Belle Vue contest in May. Leaving Knottingley by coach
at 8.30am, the Band held a pre-contest practice, sharing a rehearsal
room with the Featherstone Band. The contest culminated with a firework
display enjoyed by the bandsmen and supporters before the return trip.
(128)
The year 1954 was an exceptionally successful one and by August the Band
had already won six trophies. The degree of success had resulted in an
approach being made to the Harrogate Brass Band Association to stage a
contest in Knottingley Town Hall and on Saturday 25th September 1954 the
event took place under the adjudication of Mr. J. Broadbent of
Huddersfield. The contest comprised two sections with the hosts
competing with six other bands in the first section. Five bands featured
in the second section. The draw for playing took place at 2.30pm with
Knottingley Band being drawn fifth in their section. The contest got
underway at 3.00pm. Each section had its own awards. First position in
the first section secured the Highley Cup with the Hawkes Cup and the
Hawley Cup being awarded to the second and third placed bands. In the
second section the three trophies were the Green Shield, York Cup and
Smith’s Cup. In addition, each section had a first and second award for
the bands which were successful in the rendition of a march.
The winning band in the first section, playing the test piece ‘Moments
of Wagner’, was Altofts Colliery Band, conducted by C. Wilkinson.
Knottingley, under Whitehead, took second place and Kippax Old Band came
third. Second section winner, playing ‘Beautiful Britain’ was the Morley
Legion Band with Leeds City Band second. Arrangements were made by the
Knottingley Band secretary for the ensembles to be photographed on the
occasion of the ‘home’ contest with the six currently held trophies
prominently displayed. (129)
Terry Spencer 2006
To be continued.....
<PAGE
TWO
| CONTENTS |
PAGE FOUR>
|